The drinking age in america is a contradiction

First off, I think it's important to establish exactly what you mean by "drinking" age, and whether it should apply just to buying alcohol or to consumption period. Where I am in Manitoba Canadathe age for buying alcohol is 18, the same as our age of majority. When I was in high school here our alcohol education focussed on safety and knowing your own limit - it was never suggested, not even by the most conservative of my teachers, that we not drink.

The drinking age in america is a contradiction

Reddit Flipboard Last fall, a group of over college presidents - including the heads of Dartmouth, Virginia Tech and Duke - signed a declaration stating that the year-old drinking age is not working, and fireworks went off.

But the college presidents got what they wanted: When the age was raised to 21 in the mids, the goal was to reduce highway fatalities. But everyone knows that the 21 age limit hasn't stopped minors from drinking.

And now some experts believe it's actually contributing to an increase in extreme drinking. This is what the former president of Middlebury College in Vermont, John McCardell, believes and it's why he started the movement dedicated to lowering the age back to It may seem counterintuitive, but he argues that lowering the age will make kids safer.

It's like the old days of prohibition: As McCardell puts it, it's so widespread, it's the norm. It has simply driven it underground, behind closed doors, into the most risky and least manageable of settings.

McCardell says the law has created a dangerous culture of irresponsible and reckless behavior, unsupervised binge and extreme drinking, like something called "Six in Ten" - downing six cups of beer in ten seconds, kids trying to perfect the art of getting drunk as fast as possible by playing drinking games.

And pre-loading - downing as much of the forbidden fruit as possible before going out in order to avoid getting caught drinking in public. It's bad social policy…," McCardell said. Asked if it is unworkable or people just don't enforce it, McCardell told Stahl, "The issue of enforceability is present.

But the fact is it is so regularly and routinely avoided, that enforcement results in two arrests or convictions for every thousand violations.

Most Helpful Girl

The best we can do is try to contain it," he told Stahl. They are drinking and you cannot enforce it," Stahl remarked.

We would seal the house.

Surround the house with officers and we would write every single underage person coming out of that house. We wrote hundreds and hundreds of tickets those years.

The drinking age in america is a contradiction

All we did is we pushed it further underground," Beckner told Stahl.Over time this issue hit the national level, and the U.S. government passed a law to make the age universally 21 across the country financially discouraging any state from having a drinking age below 21 is the age of full majority in America.

Since we don’t have a better practical yardstick of maturity, that seems to me the most fair, so we’ll have to stick with that one.

A number of years ago - and I cannot confirm the actual dates on this - we tried lowering the drinking age to Drinking Facts: Alcohol Problems Around the World Kids' drinking is on the rise, a third of all booze is black market, and nearly half of us have never touched a drink.

Alcohol consumption by youth in the United States of America is an umbrella term for alcohol consumption by individuals under the age of 18 in the country.

The drinking age in america is a contradiction

Although the minimum legal age to purchase alcohol is 21 in all states (see National Minimum Drinking Age Act), the legal details for consumption vary greatly. DeJong: Raising the drinking age to 21 was a choice that was dictated by the research evidence that was coming out of the experiments in the s and early ’80s, when a lot of states switched from having a drinking age of 21 to a lower age, sometimes as low as Researchers took a look at what was going on in those states compared to.

Nov 19,  · yea the drinking age in America is ridiculous. The states themselves could lower it to about 18 or so if they wanted to. The legal age for consumption of alcohol is a state initiativeblog.com: Resolved.

Jul 08,  · So if you could drink at 18 in some states, why is the drinking age 21 now? We now have a national minimum age of 21 because of the National Minimum Drinking Age Act of In short, because of the National Minimum Drinking Age Act of This law basically told states that they had to enact a minimum drinking age of 21 or lose up to 10 percent of their federal. Oct 20,  · The legalized drinking age in America is reasonable because of federal funding, violence and car crash statistics. First, in , members of Congress threatened all states to hold 21 as the drinking age, or they would withhold federal funds, which, still holds true.
Legal drinking age - Wikipedia